Now serving in Appleton

Every bite,
crafted to please
without the wait.

Fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and sandwiches made the moment you order — that's the Toast to Toast promise, served right here in Appleton.

Explore Our Menu (920) 441-0206
Fresh Daily
Quick Service
Made to Order
A freshly made sandwich at Toast to Toast Appleton with crisp vegetables and quality bread

Made Fresh

Every single order

1565

N. Casaloma Dr

Scroll
The interior of Toast to Toast Appleton with fresh ingredients on display
Fresh ingredients being prepared in the Toast to Toast kitchen
A sandwich being assembled with fresh ingredients at Toast to Toast
The friendly team at Toast to Toast Appleton ready to serve

Appleton

Your neighborhood spot

About Us

A sandwich shop that actually cares about what's on your plate

At Toast to Toast Appleton, we believe a great sandwich starts with great ingredients and finishes with genuine care. Every order is made from scratch, every time — no shortcuts, no pre-made shortcuts.

Located on North Casaloma Drive, we've become a go-to spot for lunch rushes, quick dinners, and anything in between. Whether you're craving a hearty toasted melt or a light fresh wrap, we build it right in front of you.

Made for You

Never pre-made, always fresh

Quality First

Premium ingredients, every time

Quick Service

Fresh doesn't mean slow

Local & Proud

Part of the Appleton community

Why Toast to Toast

The difference is in the details

It's the little things that turn a good sandwich into a great experience. Here's what sets us apart.

Made to Order

Every sandwich and wrap is assembled fresh when you order — never sitting under a heat lamp or pre-packed hours ago.

Fast & Friendly

We know your time matters. Our team moves quickly without cutting corners, so you're eating fresh in no time.

Made with Care

It shows in every bite — the attention to ingredient quality, the perfect toast, the generous portions. We take pride in what we serve.

Varied Menu

From classic toasted melts to fresh wraps and satisfying sides — there's something for every craving and every dietary preference.

Community Focused

We're right here on North Casaloma Drive, serving our neighbors. Your satisfaction and return visits mean everything to us.

Easy to Find

Conveniently located on N. Casaloma Dr with easy access and plenty of parking. Stop by on your way home or during your lunch break.

Visit Us

Hours & Location

We're open seven days a week to satisfy your sandwich cravings whenever the mood strikes.

Opening Hours

Monday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Call ahead: (920) 441-0206

Find Us

1565 N Casaloma Dr

Appleton, WI 54913-8244

(920) 441-0206
Get Directions

Hungry? We're just around the corner.

Stop by Toast to Toast Appleton and taste the difference that fresh-made really makes. Your favorite sandwich is waiting.

Get Directions Call (920) 441-0206
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website